Definitions:
Schema: cognitive frameworks of the way that certain things should be - these ideas and frameworks of thinking are developed as a result of experience.
Memory: the way that one recalls information that was once processed.
Eye-witness: the witness of an incident of a third-person.
Experiments:
Loftus and Palmer, 1974
Loftus believed that memory was a reconstructive process, just as Bartlett had suggested in his "War of the Ghosts" study in 1932. She wanted to know how leading questions would affect the memory of an eye-witness. She chose to show how the memory of participants of a study could change depending on the way that a 'critical question' of an incident (i.e. a short film of a car crash) was worded. Palmer, on the other hand, was interested in seeing how questioning could change the memory of participants.
Loftus and Palmer collected participants in America in the 70s to watch a film of two cars crashing into each other. After viewing the video, the participants were as "how fast were the cars going when they hit/smashed/crashed/touched each other?" The main verb in the question was different according to the group that the participants were assigned by the researchers. As a result, Loftus and Palmer found that participants that were asked "how fast were the cars going when they crashed/smashed into each other?" had the fasted estimates, especially among subjects who were asked "how fast were the cars going when they hit each other?"
Loftus and Palmer concluded that this was due to the critical question's main verb's impression on the individual. Words such as smash and crash were attached to schemata of severe crashes, while words such as "came into contact" and "hit" were not as severe. Loftus found that leading questions could indeed change or alter the memory of the participants. This suggests that eye-witness testimonials are not accurate and can be manipulated depending on the question that is asked of the eye-witness. In a later study, Loftus and Palmer divided participants into three groups, where all three groups watched the same video once again but were asked a series of questions. One group was asked "how fast were the cards going when they smashed into each other?", another was asked "how fast were the cars going when they hit each other?" and the control group was asked questions but not of the speed of the cars. Two weeks later, participants were called back and asked whether they remember glass breaking in the videos. Suprisingly, those that were asked "how fast were the cars going when the smashed into each other?" had a 33% rate of participants saying that they had seen glass, while only 14 percent of the second group saw glass. Only 6 percent of the control group claimed they had seen glass. In reality, there was no glass. This second study suggests that initial processing that is manipulated by leading questions and schemata are liable to affect the way that consequences are processed in the future. As a result, it can be concluded that memory of witnesses, ie eye witness testimonials are susceptible to distortion and thus are no reliable. It also explains how schemata can affect the way that memories are kept, just as Bartlett had suggested in his 1932 study.
However, there are instances in psychology experiments where it has been shown that general details are remembered clearly by eye-witnesses, even under severely stressful and high-risk situations. An example is a relatively recent study that analysed the eye-witness testimonials of how the titanic sank: whether it broke in half before sinking, or sunk intact. The eye witnesses (with the exception of two people) said that the ship had sunk after breaking, despite the 'leading questions' asked by the British and American hearings a few days after the titanic rescue. While this is a general detail that was remembered by the eye witnesses, it brings upon the question of whether specific details are accurately recalled by witnesses. (Titanic eye witness study by Riniolo).
Outcome answers, summaries and evaluations of experiments pertaining to the International Baccalaureate Psychology (SL) syllabus. Blog run by 2014 International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme graduate.
Sunday, February 15, 2015
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
Potential Exam Questions
Biological Level of Analysis (SAQ)
1. Explain how determinism relates to the biological perspective.2. Explain why the reductionist approach is regarded as controversial.
3. Describe one study from the biological perspective and discuss how this study has contributed to our understanding of behavior.
4. Outline one strength and one limitation of the biological perspective in explaining one psychological or social question.
5. Explain how one hormone influences human behavior.
6. Explain how evolution has influenced human behavior.
7. Explain how one or more neurotransmitters affect human behavior.
8. Explain how one study demonstrates localisation of the brain.
9. Distinguish between localisation and lateralisation.
(LAQ)
1. Describe one study from the biological perspective and discuss how this study has contributed to our understanding of behavior.2. Evaluate two research methods that are used in the biological perspective.
3. Discuss ethical considerations related to genetic influences of behavior.
4. Discuss how and why particular research methods are used at the BLA, with reference to at least one study.
5. Discuss the use of brain imaging technoloqies to investigate the relationship between biological factors and behavior.
Cognitive Level of Analysis (SAQ)
1. Outline one assumption of the cognitive perspective. Identify one key concept based on the assumption outlined above and explain their relationship.2. Explain how one key concept from the cognitive perspective helps us understand behavior.
3. Explain one theoretical explanation of human behavior in the cognitive perspective.
4. Describe one study that investigated the schema theory.
5. Explain cognitive dissonance.
6. Outline two principles that define the cognitive level of analysis.
7. Outline how emotion affects one cognitive process.
8. Describe one ethical consideration related to one research study at the cognitive level.
9. Explain how one biological factor can affect a cognitive process.
(LAQ)
1. Assess the extent to which one model of information has helped in understanding cognitive processes.
2. Explain the extent to which free will and determinism relate to the cognitive perspective.
3. To what extent do social or cultural factors affect one cognitive process?
4. To what extent is one cognitive process reliable?
Social Cultural Level of Analysis (SAQ)
1. Describe one theory that is relevant to the social learning theory.2. Describe one theory that is relevant to the social identity theory.
3. Outline two errors in attribution.
4. Describe one theory or study on the formation of stereotypes.
5. Explain one compliance technique.
6. Explain why one particular method has been utilised in the socio-cultural level of analysis.
7. Distinguish between emic and etic.
8. Explain factors that influence conformity.
9. With reference to a study, explain conformity.
10. Discuss the use of technology in investigating the relationship between cognitive factors and behavior.
(LAQ)
1. Using empirical studies, explain two research studies that were employed by psychologists in the socio-cultural level of analysis.2. Evaluate one or more applications of one theory in the socio-cultural level of analysis.
3. Discuss factors influencing conformity.
4. Outline and evaluate schema theory with reference to studies.
5. Evaluate social identity theory with reference to relevant studies.
6. Discuss factors influencing conformity.
7. Discuss the reliability of one cognitive process.
Friday, February 7, 2014
Flashbulb Memory: Brown and Kulik (1977)
Flashbulb Memory
Brown and Kulik (1977)
Emotion can affect one's memory of an occurrence. According to LeDoux, a psychologist who argued that there are biological pathways of emotion in the brain, the arousal of emotion will facilitate the memory of events that occur during that aroused state. However, one should always remember that memory can be enhanced and amplified by an intense emotion, but will not always be accurate.
The theory of flashbulb memory was suggested by Brown and Kulik in 1977. This theory suggests that some memories are remembered distinctly - even after time had passed - because the events incited highly emotional responses at the time. The emotional events are recorded in the brain as if by the flash of a camera.
Brown and Kulik found that people had clear memories of where they had been, what they had been doing, and what had happened in events in which they were emotionally involved. Examples include when JFK and MLK Jr. had been assassinated. These participants of the study were asked if they also had flashbulb memories of personal events. Out of the 80 participants, 73 said yes for events that were especially emotional, such as traumatic events or the deaths of family members.
Explaining the actuality of the flashbulb theory: Brown and Kulik attempted to explain the biology of this effect by suggesting that there were special neural mechanisms that triggered emotional arousal for unexpected or extremely important events. This hypothesis is now supported by modern neuroscience: emotional events are better remembered than less emotional events. While reasons are still unknown to us, it could be because of the involvement of the amygdala (which is responsible for emotional responses and memory.
Neisser (1982): Argues against the flashbulb memory theory:
Neisser argued that flashbulb memory was not a cogent theory as people do not know that events are important until after the event is over. Thus, Neisser feels that the reason that some memories are especially vivid is due to their being rehearsed over and over again, once the event is known to be "important". Neisser argues that flashbulb memory is due to internal narrative: "where was I when [important event] happened?" "what was I doing when [important event] happened?" "who told me about [important event]?"...
Vivid Memories are Not Always Accurate:
In January of 1986, seven astronauts aboard the space shuttle Challenger died due to a tragic accident. This event was aired on television, so it was a shocking event for all its audience. Neisser and Harsch (1992) investigated people's memory accuracy of that event, 24 hours within the timeframe that the accident occurred, and once again 2 years later. They found that the participants were very confident in the accuracy of their memories, but 40% of them had distorted memories after the second year. Neisser and Harsch analyse that this is due to post-event information that has jumbled up their initial memory of the events. Inaccuracy of emotional memories are common, just as they are vivid. Talarico and Rubin found in 2003 that the confidence that one has of his memory is not correlated with the accuracy of that memory.
While post-event information can distort memories, it is recognised that present-views and emotions of past-events also affect one's memory. For example, men who are divorced will reflect back upon events that occurred while they were married in a more negative perception than they actually would had they remained in a successful marriage (Holmberg and Holmes 1994).
Emotion and Memory: Eye-witness testimonials of Titanic Accident
Click here for PDF with annotations.
Click here for YouTube video supplement for the PDF (read the PDF first).
Click here for YouTube video supplement for the PDF (read the PDF first).
Saturday, February 1, 2014
4.2 Reciprocity: Foot in the door, Door in the face, Low-balling, Hazing
Reciprocity
Reciprocity is a compliance technique. The reciprocity principle is that "we should treat people the way that they treat us". Reciprocity is a way of creating confidence among people in that what is given to another is not lost but rather a sign of a future obligation that enables development of various kinds of relationships and exchanges. The rule of reciprocity is so common and universal that it can be used to one's advantage, and often is.
When someone does something very kind to you, you feel obliged to repay them in some way - perhaps by being kind to them, or offering a small gift as a sign of gratitude. When you don't reciprocate what has been done to you, you feel guilty. This feeling of guilt is how reciprocity can be used for manipulation in response to a request.
Reciprocity does not always involve gifts. Reciprocity can occur when you feel that somebody has compromised on what he or she wanted for you, and you feel that you should not have them have to compromise for you once again. You feel as if the initial compromise should be acknowledged in some form or another.
1. Foot in the door technique (FITD)
A small request is used as an instrument to lead to the true, larger request. This technique is employed by getting someone to do something small, in the hopes that they will comply with even larger requests in the future. Dickerson et al (1992) found that the FITD technique was effective in promoting commitment: Dickerson et al wanted to see if they could get university students to conserve water in their dormitory showers. They first asked the students to sign a poster that said "take shorter showers. If I can do it, so can you". ( - This is the small request). Then, the researchers asked them to take a survey that was designed to make them reflect on their shower times and water wastage. Third, their shower times were monitored. The participants that had signed the petition and answered the survey had shorter shower times than the students who did not do the two things.
2. Door in the face technique (DITF)
A large request that the asker is certain will be turned down is asked first. Then, the asker asks a smaller, more feasible request (which is the true request) in an attempt to exploit reciprocity within the subject. People are more likely to respond positively to the second request because they feel as if the asker has already had to compensate once, with the larger request. Cialdini et al (1975) studied the effectiveness of the DITF technique by pretending to be representatives of the "County Youth Counselling Programme" and asking college students if they were willing to chaperone a group of juvenile delinquents on a day trip to the zoo (a large, unfeasible request for college kids). 83% of the college students refused. To another group, Cialdini et al initially asked them if they would be willing to sign up to work for two hours a week as counselors for a minimum of two years (an unfeasible request). Nobody agreed to this task either. Then, the true request was made ( - and it seemed a lot more reasonable, in comparison to the first request!). The college students were asked if they would be willing to chaperone a day trip to the zoo for juvenile delinquents: 50% of the students agreed to chaperone. This experiment shows how effective the DITF technique can be, and thus how it can be exploited in real life.
3. Low-balling
Low-balling is a persuasion technique that is used when something that is very feasible is requested, but the request is later changed to a larger request that is harder to agree with. The concept is, that because the subjects already agreed to a project, that they would not refuse once the details were changed. Cialdini et al (1974) demonstrated the effect of low-balling in a class of first-year psychology students. He asked them to participate in a study on cognition, and that they would meet at 7:00 in the morning. Only 24 per cent of students were willing to participate due to the early time. Next, another group was told to meet, without being told the time. 56 per cent of students agreed to participate. It was only then that they were told the meeting time would be at 7:00 am. However, 95 per cent of those who already said that they would participate actually showed up, showing how effective it is to low-ball.
4. Hazing
Hazing is a controversial practice of reciprocity where a series of initiation rites that are performed in order for a person to join a certain exclusive social group. Hazing is similar to initiation rites that are seen in various cultures, such as in African tribes where there are initiation rites for young men to indicate that they have become adults. Hazing continues despite being painful, humiliating or dangerous because it is the individual's choice (initially) that he/she wants to join a group. At the time of decision, the individual is cognisant of the pain that he/she will have to endure to join the group, but resolves to join anyway. During the hazing, one has to rationalise that the pain, or the endurance of it, is "worth it" if they could become a part of the group. Once hazing is accomplished and the individual is accepted into the group, they are filled with a sense of accomplishment and ingroup favoritism. Young (1963) found that out of 54 tribal cultures, those that had the most stoic hazing rites were those that had the greatest group solidarity.
4.2 Emic and Etic Concepts
Emic and Etic Concepts
Outcome: explain, using concepts, emic and etic concepts:
1. EMIC
- Emic research studies one culture alone to understand culture-specific behaviors.
- Researchers attempt to study behavior through the eyes of the people who live in that culture. They try to "walk in their subjects' shoes". The way the phenomenon is linked to the culture and the meaning it has in the culture is emphasized through the emic concept.
- Emic research attempts to focus on the norms, values, motives and customs of the members of the culture as they (vis: the researchers) interpret and understand it themselves. Emic concepts are explained in the researcher's own words.
Examples of emic approaches in psychology:
a) Bartlett 1932: mentioned the ability of the Swazi herdmen to recall individual characteristics of their cattle. Bartlett explains: "Swazi culture revolves around the possession and care of cattle and thus it is important for people to recognise their animals as it is a sign of their wealthiness" - Bartlett attempts to understand the phenomenon of the Swazi herdsmen memorising individual cattle through analysis of the culture of Swazi people and why they would need to remember which cattle belonged to them. This is an emic approach: Bartlett is walking in the shoes of the Swazi people.
b) Yap 1967: suggested the term culture-bound syndrome as a culture-specific disorder that can only be understood within a specific cultural context ( - see how this is already taking an emic approach). Among the Yoruba people of West Africa, it is believed that spirits might come into the possession of one's soul, and that person can be treated by spells by a medicine man or a healer. (More about culture-bound syndrome here)
2. ETIC
- Etic approach compares psychological phenomena across cultures to find out what might be universal in human behaviors.
- Etic approach aims to compare and contrast cultural phenomena across cultures to investigate whether phenomena are culture-specific or universal.
Examples of etic approaches in psychology:
a) Kashima and Triandis 1986: identified that there was a difference in the way that people explain their own success when they compared Japanese and American people talking about their respective successes. American participants tended to explain that they were successful due to their dispositional factors (such as diligence, integrity, shrewdness) while Japanese participants lent their success to situational factors (such as luck). American participants thus displayed self-serving bias and the Japanese displayed modesty bias: the cultures in which each participant came from has influenced the way that they perceive themselves and their successes. American countries promote individualism, while Asian countries such as Japan value collectivism and modesty.
b) Berry 1967: replicated Asch's conformity experiment to study whether conformity rates along the Temne in Sierra Leone in Africa and the Inuits of Canada could be linked to social norms and socialisation practices. The Temne (which had an agricultural economy) had high rates of conformity, while the Innuits (who were a community of lone hunters) had low rates of conformity. Additionally, Temne culture valued obedience in childrearing as the culture is dependent on cooperative farming. On the other hand, Innuit culture valued self-reliance in childrearing practices as hunting alone required integrity and the ability to solve decisions on one's own.
Social Representations and Stereotypes
Social Representations
Social representations are defined as the shared beliefs and explanations help by a society in which we live, or the group to which we belong. (Moscovici, 1973). Moscovici argued that social representations were at the foundation of social cognition: social representations help us make sense of our world and master it, enabling communication to take place among members in a group. That is to say, cultural schemata are funamental to the identity of the group, and provide the group with common understanding and a ground for communication.
Cultures have different views and ideals: cultural schemata are what influence these differences. Adler (1990) asked a Russian mother what it meant for her children to share something: "to use it together". He asked an American mother what it meant for her children to share something "to take turns using it independently".
Howarth (2002) carried out focus-group interviews with adolescent girls in Brixton, to study how these girls described and evaluated themselves. Howarth found that the girls had a positive view of being "from Brixton" which was contrasted with the views of people outside of Brixton. This may be a sign of positive social identity due to ingroup favoritism.
Stereotypes and their effects on behavior
A stereotype is defined as a social perception of an individual in terms of his or her group membership. Stereotypes are generalisations that are made about a group that are then attributed to each individual member of a group. These generalisations can end up being positive or negative. Example: "women are talented speakers" vs "all women do is gossip"
Stereotypes are able to influence the person who believes it, as well as who the stereotype is referring to. Researchers explain stereotyping as a result of schema processing.
Stereotype threats: the effect of stereotypes on an individual's performance:
A stereotype threat is something that occurs when an individual is in a situation where there is a threat of being judged or treated stereotypically, or a fear of doing something that might inadvertently confirm the stereotype.
Steele and Aronson (1995): A study on stereotype threat
Aim: to see the effect that stereotype threats had on performance.
Procedure: They carried out an experiment to see the effect of stereotype threats on performance. A 30 minute verbal test made up of difficult multiple choice questions were given to African American students and European American students. In the first trial, the researchers told the students that they were being "genuinely tested of verbal ability". As a result, the African American students did much worse than the European American students. However, in the second trial, when the researchers told the students that they were being tested to see "how certain problems were generally solved", the African American's scores increased compared to the first trial's, and were up to par with the European American students. This shows that stereotype threat can happen to any member in a group that is stereotyped, and can affect the way that they perform or behave. This may explain why some racial or social groups seem to identify themselves as more inept than other groups. Believing in such stereotypes can actually lower ability or performance.
Steele (1997): stereotype threats turns on spotlight anxiety which causes emotional distress and pressure that may undermine an individual's performance ability. This is why students under stereotype threats can under-perform, and fulfill the stereotype that is being place on them. Additionally, stereotypes and stereotype threats can limit student's education prospects.
Spencer et. al (1977): Testing the effect stereotype threats have on intellect
Spencer et al tested how stereotype threats can influence a student's intellectual capability.
Procedure: the researchers gave difficult maths test to students who were strong in mathematics, predicting that women under stereotype threat would underperform compared to the men taking the test. (Stereotype: women are worse at math than men). The stereotype threat causes women taking the test to see mathematics as an important part of their self-definition, so that a stereotype threat might result in an interfering pressure under test conditions.
Result: stereotype threat had caused women to significantly underperform against men, while their mathematics capabilities were the same as the men's. The validity of the experiment is justified through the same experiment occurring with literature tests: women did not underperform as they were not under any stereotype threats.
How stereotypes form
Tajfel argues that stereotypes are a natural cognitive process from social categorisation (categorising who is in the ingroup / outgroup), it does not explain how stereotypes form. Stereotypes are a salient part of our social and cultural environment: we learn stereotypes through daily interactions, conversations and the media. Additionally, they are not based only on an individual's experience with a member of a group. They are also influenced by cultural and social factors: stereotypes are contextualised, and not simply the results of an individual's cognitive process. Stereotypes are often held by large groups as social representations (=social representations: the beliefs that are held by a group). Campbell (1967) maintains that it is this convergence with personal experience and the influence of social and cultural environments that cause stereotypes to form. His grain of truth hypothesis argues that an experience with an individual from a group will be generalised to the whole group.
Hamilton and Gifford (1976) have another hypothesis as to how stereotypes were formed: Hamilton and Gifford argue that stereotypes are a product of illusory correlation: people see a relationship between two variables even when they are not related. This occurs when people associate a social group to the specific behaviors of those that belong to that group. This illusory correlation lead people to make false associations and links between unrelated variables. They come in many forms and some culturally based prejudices are a result of illusory correlation.
Once illusory correlations are made, people seek out or remember information that supports that relationship of variables. This is an example of confirmation bias: when people look for evidence that supports their theory, and ignore all evidence that goes against it. In context to stereotypes, the individuals in a group that do not conform to the stereotype given about that group are ignored, or dismissed as outliers. Confirmation bias is why stereotypes are unlikely to disappear.
Snyder and Swann (1978) conducted a study in which they told female college students that they would meet a person who was either an introvert or an extrovert. They were then asked to prepare a set of questions for the person they were going to meet. Participants came up with questions that corresponded to the type of person that they were told that they would meet. Those that thought they were meeting an introvert had questions like "What do you dislike about parties?", "Are there times when you wish you were more outgoing?" and those that thought they were meeting extroverts prepared questions like "what do you do to liven up a party?". Snyder and Swann concluded that the questions confirmed the participants' stereotypes of the personality types that they were told they would meet.
It was also found that a stereotype may be adopted by a person in order to be in consensus with an ingroup. Rogers and Frantz (1962) found that white immigrants to Zimbabwe held more prejudices and stereotypes of the people there than were held back in America. This was thought to be so that the immigrants could be in agreement with the ingroup (whites) in Zimbabwe.
The Princeton Trilogy
1. Katz and Braley (1933) performed an experiment investigating how traditional social stereotypes had a cultural basis by asking 100 males students that attended Princeton University to choose 5 words from a list of 84 words to describe different ethnicities. Results showed that there were many words chosen for certain ethnic groups, and that they confirmed negative stereotypes. Additionally, they were extremely positive about their own ethnic group (ingroup favoritism to maintain a successful social identity). Conclusion: as most of the Princeton students never came into contact with the ethnic groups that they categorised, it was assumed that stereotypes were formed through gateways such as media and cultural views.
2. Gilbert (1951) replicated the experiment of Katz and Braley but found that more people were reluctant to categorise ethnic groups into words that defined them. There was also less uniformity of agreement about unfavorable traits compared to the 1933 study. However, the conclusion from the 1933 study was also concluded in this study as the students held extremely negative views of the Japanese ethnic group (most likely due to Pearl Harbor) and this information was relayed to them from television, radio and news.
3. Karlins et. al (1969) the most recent replication of this study was one where students objected to classifying ethnic groups. When the task was completed, there was greater agreement on the stereotypes assigned to the different groups compared to the 1951 Gilbert study. Researchers concluded that this was a reemergence of social stereotyping but in the direction of a more favorable stereotype image.
![]() |
| Stereotype formation |
Social Identity Theory (Tajfel 1970)
Social Identity Theory (Tajfel and Turner, 1979)
Social Identity is the way that one identifies with himself in relation to his memberships to various social groups, and the value of being in that group ( - "Social comparison": when one weighs the pros and cons of being in his own group [ingroup] and another group [outgroup] )
Individuals try to maintain a positive self-image and self-esteem. The groups that they belong in, and the social comparisons of the groups and other groups will affect how the individual values himself. To protect oneself from low self-esteem (which would arise from being in a group with little advantages,) the individual may express ingroup favoritism, and a pattern of discrimination with the outgroup.
= When a social comparison results in a positive outcome for the individual's ingroup, the need for a positive social identity is fulfilled. However, if the outcome is negative, this could result in low self-esteem, shame, embarrassment, etc.
Cialdini et al (1976): College students were more likely to wear school gear (hats, sweaters, shirts) when their football team wins a match. This is mostly likely due to the students' need for a positive self-concept / self-image. The positive self-image brought on by winning a game can result in bias and predilection for ingroups, and all the things the ingroup represents.
Intergroup discrimination can be a way to uphold a positive social identity for an ingroup.
![]() |
| How social identity is built by an individual. |
Tajfel (1970) Experiment in intergroup discrimination: minimal group paradigm
Aim: to see if boys who were randomly placed in groups based on a meaningless task would display ingroup favoritism and intergroup discrimination.
Experiment 1: 64 schoolboys of ages 14 to 15 were invited to a psychology laboratory in groups of eight. The boys all knew each other well. Boys were seen moving clusters on a computer screen, and were told to estimate the number of dots that were in each cluster. Boys were then randomly assigned to groups such as "over-estimator" and "under-estimator". Then, boys had to hand out money to the other boys in the experiment. All the boys knew was whether the other boy was in or not in his own group.
Experiment 2: boys were randomly allocated into groups according to which artist's art they liked better. The boys then had to award money to other boys.
Results: boys gave more money to members in their own category (i.e. boys that were in the ingroup). In the second experiment, the boys tried to maximise the difference between the two groups. Both experiments indicate ingroup favoritism which supports the predictions of the social identity theory.
Evaluate: results contributed to the development of the social identity theory. Tajfel demonstrated that a minimal group is all that is necessary for individuals to exhibit discrimination against outgroups. This experiment was criticised for being too artificial, and having demand characteristics. Boys might have thought the task was competitive, which caused them to react the way that they did (i.e. exhibit ingroup favoritism and discriminate between the outgroup).This study also established that intergroup conflict is not necessary to create induce ingroup favoritism.
Social identity theory has contributed to explaining how stereotypes, prejudices and conformity to ingroup norms have occurred.
Thursday, January 30, 2014
6.3 Developmental Psychology: Gender
The Formation and Development of Gender Roles
OUTCOME: ASSESS THE EXTENT TO WHICH BIOLOGICAL, COGNITIVE AND SOCIOCULTURAL FACTORS INFLUENCE HUMAN DEVELOPMENT.---
Focus questions:
1. Are there psychological differences between men and women, or are the differences in behavior due to socialisation?
2. When does gender-role socialisation begin?
3. What is gender identity, gender role and gender constancy?
---
Nearly all societies have expectations of the ways males and females should behave. In order to live up to these expectations, children will learn what it means to be a boy or a girl in the culture that it grows up in.
Thus, it is generally accepted that gender role socialisation begins as soon as a newborn child has been identified as a girl or a boy. The child will be given a name, and that name will already be a definition of the sexuality of that child. The world will treat the children according to their gender.
| Gender Roles are determined once the infant's gender is determined soon before / after birth. |
Men and women occupy different roles in society, and ideas of what is typical behavior for a sex is according to the biological sex of an individual. Children, once assuming gender roles, are raised accordingly to their genders (so as to facilitate the development of gender roles).
Whiting and Edwards (1973) found that girls were more nurturing and made more physical contact, while boys were more aggressive, dominant and engaged in rough play. Whiting and Edwards studied children from Kenya, Japan, India, the USA, Mexico and the Philippines. Whiting et al determined that the gender differences in the six cultures as differences in the socialisation pressures that those cultures put upon children. (EG: to what extent older female siblings were put in charge of taking care of their younger siblings).
---
Nurture or nature?
There has been an ongoing debate on whether gender roles are developed behaviorally or culturally. The general consensus is that biological (hormonal) factors are important in the development of gender identity, but cultural factors are also important. (An extremist nature argument contends that a child's gender identity is completely determined by the physiology of the child such as prenatal exposure to certain hormones, and is unchangeable.) (An extremist nurture view claims that the way a child is dressed, treated and taught will be critical factors in the development of his or her gender identity.
---
Biological Explanations of the Difference in Females and Males
Evolutionary psychologists tend to argue that the difference in the evolutionary pressures faced by men and women are what account for the gender differences between males and females. the natural selection process in evolution is what brought upon vast differences in the physiology and the psychology between the man and the woman.
This view argues that men are aggressive and competitive because it increases their chances to mate with a female. Women are nurturing, caring, empathetic and gentle, which are also evolutionary adaptations in order to attract a mate and produce / care for offspring.
Critics of this theory: argue that differences in gender roles are not a result of evolution, but rather a consequence of the different roles that cultures assign to men and woman, as well as agreement on socialisation practices that prepare children for these roles.
The BIOLOGICAL perspective: PSYCHOSEXUAL DIFFERENTIATION:
Some researchers argue that behavioral differences between children can be explained by the hormones and the changes in the brain structure as they develop. The theory of psychosexual differentiation holds that all humans were born with an innate (biological) predisposition to behave like females or to behave like males. This theory stresses that the prenatal hormones that are secreted and absorbed by the infant are what affects the gender and gender-appropriate behavior of the children. This theory undermines the important of social interaction / societal influences in gender-related behaviors and roles.
---
The role of SOCIALISATION on gender behavior: BIOSOCIAL THEORY OF GENDER ROLE DEVELOPMENT
The biosocial theory of gender role development values the role that society and socialisation have on the individual's gender identity and role. This theory was first suggested by Money and Ehrhardt in 1972. This theory sees that the interaction between prenatal hormones and biological indicators of gender differences (i.e. from the psychosexual differentiation theory) and socialisation are important indicators in the way a gender role develops within an individual. Biosocial theory of gender role development argues that the development of a gender role and the adherence to the gender role during growth (/development) depend on socialisation. Money argues that children are gender neutral at birth which means that they can be raised and reared to grow up as either a female or a male.
Money and his theory of gender neutrality
Money based his theory off of case studies with individuals that were born with ambiguous sexual reproductive organs. He found that children who were born as biological females can be raised as boys and they will act like boys, and vice versa. Thus he arrived at the theory of gender neutrality: "humans are not born with a gender identity, and do not have one until two years of life. Therefore if a child is raised as a specific gender from before the age of two, they will be act like the gender that they were raised as." = "It is possible to reassign sex to children with intersex reproductive organs due to surgical disasters."
Money and David Reimer (a subject)
David Reimer (birth name Bruce) was born an identical twin in Winnipeg, Manitoba. At 6 months of age both boys were mistakenly diagnosed with phimosis, a natural condition of the infant penis. The so-called doctor Jean-Marie Huot botched the first circumcision completely destroying Bruce's penis. Twin Brian's circumcision was canceled; he made a full recovery from his "condition" of phimosis, without further treatment.
Shortly after the botched circumcision Bruce's mother Janet saw a television interview with John Money, a physician from John Hopkins Hospital who worked with cases of gender identity, transsexuality and intersex conditions. Janet wondered if perhaps she had found an answer to the horrific situation her baby was in, could Bruce be raised as a girl?
John Money thought he saw an opportunity to prove gender is learned behavior, and Bruce was an ideal subject with his twin brother Brian as a scientific control. Bruce was reassigned as Brenda. Money reported several times that the experiment was a success, and Brenda had adjusted well and liked to help her mother with traditionally female tasks around the house. Money built much of his career and theories of gender on the "successful" outcome of this case. Reality was far from the rosy domestic picture Money was reporting, Brenda never adjusted.
As a young teenager, refusing to take the prescribed female hormones and facing vaginoplasty surgery, Brenda rebelled to the point that her father broke down and confessed to her the botched circumcision which had led to the forced feminization. Brenda immediately assumed a male identity and took the name David. (Text taken from http://youtu.be/bw24j0Litlc)
---
The Social Learning Theory and Development of Gender Roles
OUTCOME: DISCUSS THE FORMATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF GENDER ROLES IN PEOPLESocial Learning Theory (Albert Bandura, 1977).
The social learning theory is a theory that suggests that children learn by observing and emulating adult models that are alike to them. Thus, this theory could explain why certain characteristics belong to the female category, and why others belong to the male category. The social learning theory reasons that boys and girls behave differently because they are treated differently by their parents and others.
For example, it is known that the toys that are given to boys and girls are different. Boys may get air-guns, truck toys or trains as toys, while girls prefer to receive dolls, doll-houses and other toys.Generally, children learn to behave in ways that are rewarded by others, while they also learn to avoid behaviors that are punished or frowned upon by others. (=Direct tuition). The social learning theory, as you may remember from socio-cultural psychology, involves the following steps:
1. observation
2. retention
3. motor reproduction
4. motivation
There are two important factors in the social learning theory when considering the development of gender roles. One is the necessary rewards / punishments that will serve as instigators to behave in a certain way (or to emulate a model). A reward will typically be given for a gender-appropriate behavior, and a punishment will be given if the behavior is gender-inappropriate. Additionally, there is an important factor that the model must be alike to the subjects (children who are developing gender identities and roles). The modelling of behavior will be done through same-sex adult models; the child will learn through observing the way the model behaves throughout the day, By observing how others of the same sex behave in certain ways, children receive positive reinforcement for behaviors that are considered gender-appropriate. (Bandura 1977). See the Bobo doll experiment in 1961, where there were interesting reactions of children (with already developed sense of gender roles in a society) against gender-inappropriate behaviors of models.
Children can act as gender police, Fagot in 1985 observes. Gender police is a term that refers to how informed a child is of gender roles, and how they react in the face of other children that have not fully understood gender-appropriate or inappropriate behavior. Fagot found that in an observational study of children ages 12-25 months, boys made fun of boys who played with girls' toys, while girls disliked it when boys acted girly. The children in this study were very young, which means that it is unlikely that gender identity had been achieve at this point. Thus, the reactions upon having a few gender-inappropriate behaviors can be seen as a socially learned behavior, through the observance of daily social interaction or other sources of information such as TV.
Sroufe et al (1993) observed that children around the age of 10-11 years old were more popular if they acted according to their gender. These studies indicate that children establish a kind of social control in relation to gender-roles very easily, and that peer-socialiastion might be an important factor in growth.
The social learning theory takes into account the social and cultural context in which gender socialisations occur. It predicts that children acquire internal standards of gender roles and gender-based behaviors through reward and punishment, from models, and from observing their actions.
Weaknesses of the social learning theory:
- it cannot explain why there seems to be considerable variation in the degree to which individual boys and girls conform to the gender role
- the theory suggests that gender is more or less passively acquired by an individual, through simple observation.
Developing gender identities and roles is a rather complex process that involves cognitive (social learning theory) factors in addition to social factors (biosocial theory of gender role development) and biological factors (the psychosexual differentiation).
---
Gender Schema Theory and the development of gender roles within children
Schemas are mental frameworks of perception that originate from an individual's experiences and expectations for situations in the future. The gender schema theory therefore is a mental representation of the genders and their behaviors. An example of a gender schema would be stereotypes. The gender schema theory is based on the fact that knowledge of gender roles and gender identity may be developed through cognitive processes. Children constantly construct gender identity based on their experiences (ie schemas turn into stereotypes).
| Gender schemata can turn into gender stereotypes |
Because children tend to categorise on the basis of gender this leads the children seeing the girls and boys as different existences. Once they have identified their own gender identites, they will be motivated to be alike the others in their gender group, causing them to observe their own sex-roles more closely (i.e. observation Albert Bandura's constructivist theory of social learning). Martin and Halvorson state that children have schemata of what are suitable for boys and what are suitable for girls. They thus have a gender schema for their own group (this is an in-group) and a gender schema for the other gender-group (this will be known as the out-group). These schemata include attributes, activities and objects that are gender consistent or definite.
Gender schemata determine what attracts a child's attention, what they are meant to pay attention to, what attracts them, and what they remember. A boy is more likely to imitate same-sex models because gender schemas serve as an internal, self-regulating standard.
Martin et al in 1983 showed how information that is not consistent with a child's schemata will be distorted when recalled. They used a sample of 5-6 year old boys and girls. The boys and girls were shown photos of males and females that were doing activities that pertained to the children's gender schemas (females that play with dolls, or of boys who are holding guns). However, there were also photos of gender-inappropriate actions, such as a female holding a gun. The interesting result was that any information that was not in line with the children's schemata (anomalies such as the female with the gun) were altered within the children's minds so that it was a male holding the gun. This is an example of assimilation due to the strength of gender schemata.
Strengths of the gender schema theory:
- this theory suggests that memory and gender role formations are a constructivist process, rather than a passive process like it is suggested in the social learning theory of gender role development.
- this theory can explain why children's gender roles do not change over time: regardless of time, because evidence that supports the framework of gender identity within the child will continue to be paid attention to.
Limitations of the gender schema theory:
- there is too much focus on the individual child in gender development
- in reality, social and cultural factors should be taken into account: not only cognitive processes
- we do not know how these gender schema developed (through observations of models, such as the social learning theory?)
---
Sociocultural Influences on Development of Gender Roles
OUTCOME: EXPLAIN CULTURAL VARIATION IN GENDER ROLES.
Focus questions:
Are gender roles universal?
What is the evidence that gender roles are biologically based?
---
Cross-cultural studies of gender have been an effective method to determine the extent to which culture plays a role in allocating gender roles. For as long as can be remembered, there have been different jobs for women and men, simply because women were weaker, had childbearing and nurturing to do, while men were stronger and larger. Work that was most compatible with women were assigned to women, and the men did the rest of the work. Eagley in 1987 suggested the social role theory that suggests that gender stereotypes arise from the differing roles that men and women occupy. Usually, societies have "gender ideologies" that promote some roles to women, and others to men, while simultaneously restricting access to that role to the "inappropriate sex". These societal beliefs are integrated into the culture: through religion, through social norms, and through daily communications.
Williams and Best (1990) argued against Eagly, suggesting that gender stereotypes arose from the gender roles of men and women. The gender stereotypes will establish what individuals should expect from each sex; that is, they provide models for gender role socialisation.
Research by Best et al (1977) shows that gender stereotypes (expectations) of females and males are adopted by an individual at a very early age. A cross-cultural study that included Ireland, the UK and the USA, with subjects that were five years old and eight years old. The majority of boys and girls in both groups identified that females were more gentle, calm and soft-hearted, whereas boys were aggressive, rough, and cruel. More characteristics were stereotyped by those in the eight-year old group than the five-year old group. The eight-year old group's stereotypes were similar to the same stereotypes of gender that adults held.
Mead was an anthropologist that set out to suggest that gender roles were more culturally influenced than it was thought to be at the time. Mead believed that gender roles and traits were merely the result of cultural beliefs in a society, and not dependent on biology. In 1935 Mead compared gender roles in three tribes in New Guinea, all of the tribes at a 100 miles radius from each other. The first tribe will be known as A, the second tribe will be referred to as B, and the third tribe will be referred to as C.
Results:
A- this tribe displayed very different gender roles from the Western world. Men and women were all cooperative, loving and caring - which are considered "feminine" in the Western world. Both men and women took care of their children in great care, and would share tasks for crops and other chores.
B- in this tribe, both men and women were aggressive, rough, competitive and arrogant. They were also emotionally unresponsive. The men and women alike were known to be consistently quarreling, and neither cared for the children very much which resulted in the children becoming self-reliant at a young age.
C- this tribe had opposite gender roles from the Western world: men gossiped and were concerned with accessories and garments while women were responsible for the production of food and other chores.
Interpretation:
Mead found the results of her study to support her theory that gender roles were influenced greatly by cultural norms and beliefs, instead of being biologically hardwired within people. Mead's study shows that labor division is not the same in all cultures, and that roles of gender are not universal.
Criticisms:
Her self-report is not reliable (-)
Her view undermines the importance of biological influences on gender-roles (-)
The study takes on an etic approach (a scientist looking into a foreign culture) which could be biased to some extent (-)
She showed that cross-cultural research can provide evidence to falsify theories (+)
She used three tribes that were not exposed to a Western culture (+)
---
In Denmark, the gender roles of men and women differ slightly from those that face men and women in the Western world. Men are more involved in the child-care process of a new born, where they will take paternal leave in order to care for their child. Additionally, new fathers form communities on websites to share tips, questions and stories about their child. Women are often found to be working in place of men during this time. Men in a survey by Reinicke (2006) answered that it was important for them to have a close relationship with their baby and take part in caring for the child.
This indicates that Mead had validity in her theory that gender roles are a result of cultural beliefs and norms rather than biology.
Monday, October 7, 2013
BLA: Neurotransmitters VS Hormones
Quick Notes:
Neurotransmitters: any chemicals that are capable of synaptic transmission of a nerve impulse / action potential across a synapse. Neurotransmitters are involved in the transmission of an action potential from a presynaptic neuron to a postsynaptic neuron. Neurotrasmitters are able to carry these nerve impulses quickly - much quicker than hormones. However, the effect that neurotransmitters have on behavior of the organism is short-lasting as well. This is because constant stimulation of a receptor will cause habituation.
Hormones: chemicals that are secreted by the endocrine system of an organism. Any gland within the endocrine system is capable of releasing a hormone. The hormone is transported through the body by the blood stream; it is able to access (essentially) all the cells of the organism. However, the hormone will have target cells, where they are only able to bind to specific protein receptors on the membranes of those same cells (i.e. the hormones will not alter the nature of all the cells within a body). Hormones tend to take a longer amount of time to affect the organism, but the effects are longer lasting than that of neurotransmitters.
Neurotransmitters: any chemicals that are capable of synaptic transmission of a nerve impulse / action potential across a synapse. Neurotransmitters are involved in the transmission of an action potential from a presynaptic neuron to a postsynaptic neuron. Neurotrasmitters are able to carry these nerve impulses quickly - much quicker than hormones. However, the effect that neurotransmitters have on behavior of the organism is short-lasting as well. This is because constant stimulation of a receptor will cause habituation.
Hormones: chemicals that are secreted by the endocrine system of an organism. Any gland within the endocrine system is capable of releasing a hormone. The hormone is transported through the body by the blood stream; it is able to access (essentially) all the cells of the organism. However, the hormone will have target cells, where they are only able to bind to specific protein receptors on the membranes of those same cells (i.e. the hormones will not alter the nature of all the cells within a body). Hormones tend to take a longer amount of time to affect the organism, but the effects are longer lasting than that of neurotransmitters.
Sunday, October 6, 2013
BLA: The Role of Hormones in Human Behavior
Arnold Berthold (1849)
An experiment demonstrating the role of hormones in animals.
Hormone tested: testosterone
Animal tested: roosters
Prior Knowledge: Testosterone is a hormone that is responsible for:
1. Development of male sex organs in an human embryo
2. Secondary development of sex characteristics in males during puberty
3. Sex drive throughout a male's life
Arnold Berthold was the curator of a local zoo in Gottingen. He performed one of the first endocrine / hormone experiments in history.
Aim: Berthold aimed to identify the effects of testosterone in behavior through the castration of roosters
Subjects: six castrated roosters
Method:
- Quasi-experiment: a quasi-experiment is a study that has most of the characteristics of a normal study, but is unable to control some potential factors (such as age or sex of the subjects)
Berthold surgically castrated six healthy roosters. Castration refers to when the testicles are removed, which consequentially stops the subject's production of the hormone testosterone. Then, Berthold divided the roosters into three groups of two roosters.
- Group 1: control group - the roosters were kept capons
- Group 2: the roosters were transplanted the testicles of another rooster
- Group 3: the roosters were re-implanted with their own testicles
Although the hypothesis is unknown, because Berthold was trying to identify the roles of testosterone in male behavior, it is likely that he predicted that testosterone was involved in the male-specific behavior of roosters.
Results:
It was observed that the castrated roosters were less aggressive, less masculine, and had lost their interest towards hens. Berthold observed the castrated roosters to have a lesser tendency to crow, fight and mate.
The roosters that had reacquired testicles (group 2 & group 3) behaved normally, as any other uncastrated rooster.
Autopsies of the roosters in groups 2 and 3 revealed that the re-implanted testicles did not re-establish nerve connections with the rest of the body.
Conclusion:
Testicles release a hormone (testosterone) that influences aggression and dominant male behaviors.
Connection to the topic: hormones in human behavior:
- Berthold was able to identify that a biochemical released by the testes (i.e. testicles) was largely the cause of male characteristics and male behavior. This is because the roosters that were kept castrated (group 1) did not show any male specific behaviors and also had lost physical characteristics of male roosters - see image below.
| Group 1 / Group 2 / Group 3 |
Evaluation:
- Berthold only tested animals: validity of this experiment is only relative to the tested species
- ^ However, human males also have testicles and their endocrine systems also secrete testosterone, so the results may be highly relevant to the human male population
- Animals were harmed in this experiment
- No humans were harmed in this experiment
- The experiment was performed in the mid 19th century: outdated
- This study encourages the study of the endocrine system and hormones in relation to human behavior.
Tuesday, September 24, 2013
Internal Assessment: Writing Your Introduction
An example / template of a first-draft introduction: Craik and Tulving, 1975
HL Introduction
At any given time, humans are overwhelmed with information: sensory information (such as smells, sights and sounds), information from fellow humans, or input from mass media. While we have grown accustomed to subconsciously filtering and interpreting the constant input of information, some pieces of information are remembered better than others. What determines the ability to remember those pieces of information? It could be the importance of the information, relative to the person, or perhaps the degree of depth in which the information is processed. The discipline that studies how individuals process and remember information is within cognitive psychology: the study of the mental processes of people.
Craik & Tulving (1975) attempted to understand how some information is recalled with more ease than others. The study primary came into being in an attempt to falsify the Atkinson-Shiffrin model of memory (1967), and support Craik & Lockhart's levels-of-processing model (1972). The Atkinson-Shiffrin model of memory proposes that human memory follows a sequence of three stages: sensory memory to short-term memory to long-term memory. Craik and Tulving thus attempted theorize that memory retention was greatly affected by the depth of processing performed by the individual, rather than chronology. The aim of their 1975 study was to test different levels of processing in subjects to investigate whether depth of processing was involved in memory retention.
In the experiment, the information was presented to the subjects in the form of simple two-syllable nouns; before being shown the words, subjects were asked questions that would require a certain type of processing. The three different levels of processing that the subjects would use were: phonemic or structural ( - a shallow level of processing), and semantic processing ( - a deep level of processing). The phonemic level of processing would be used by subjects when the given question was related to the way a word sounds, structural levels of processing would be used when given questions concerned the physical appearance of the word, and semantic levels of processing would be used when questions inquired on the context the word could be used in. Craik and Tulving hypothesized that words processed via deeper levels (i.e. semantic processing) would take longer to answer but yield a more elaborate memory trace and higher recall performance.
For this study, the aim is to see if information is more easily retained when it is processed through "deeper processing" or "shallow processing". Use of the same levels of processing as Craik and Tulving will be utilized to test the memory-retention in subjects.
Monday, September 16, 2013
BLA: Martinez and Kesner (1991)
Martinez and Kesner, 1991
On Acetylcholine and its Role on Memory Formation
Before reading, you should be comfortable with:- neurotransmitters
- the principles of the biological level of analysis
- experimental methods used in the biological level of analysis
What is this study about?
This study was performed in the biological perspective, where lab rats were used to test the role that a neurotransmitter has in the formation of memory.
Aim?
To see the role that acetylcholine has on memory formation.
How was this "formation of memory" tested with lab rats?
The lab rats were put under three different controls:
1. Rats were injected with scopolamine (drug), which is known to block acetylcholine receptor proteins on the post-synaptic neurones. This means that acetylcholine, a hormone expected to help form memories cannot travel from one neuron to another, i.e. no nerve impulse is sent across neurones.
2. Rats were injected with physostigmine, a drug that is antagonistic towards acetylcholinesterase. Cholinesterase (or acetylcholinesterase) is what cleans up the acetylcholine from receptor proteins on the post-synaptic neurones, returning the neurones to their "resting potential", where no nerve impulse is being sent. Physostigmine blocks cholinesterase which prevents this "cleaning-up" of acetylcholine.
3. Rats were not injected or altered in any form at all.
Design:
- Laboratory experiment
- Controlled variables (i.e. 3 conditions of the rats, drug amount, maze complexity)
Procedure:
1. All rats were placed in the maze individually and completed the maze (maze had reward of food at the end)
2. Rats were given their respective treatments (see 3 groups above)
3. Rats were placed in maze individually and time taken to complete maze was measured
Results?
- Condition 1 (rats that were injected with scopolamine) took the longest to complete the maze
- Condition 2 (rats that were injected with physostigmine) took the shorted amount of time to complete the maze
- Condition 3 (rats with no treatment) had maze-completion times between the condition 1 and condition 2 rats
Interpretation?
- Scopolamine has the effect of preventing or slowing down the process of memory formation. This can be concluded because the rats given scopolamine took the longest to complete their mazes. Acetylcholine is involved in memory formation because scopolamine is what blocks acetylcholine receptors.
- Acetylcholine is involved in memory formation because the condition 2 rats were quickest in completing the maze: their injection of physostigmine prevented the removal of acetylcholine from the receptor proteins of the post-synaptic neurones.
- The more acetylcholine is available, the more productive memory formation is. This can be concluded because condition 3 rats were in-between the other two conditions in terms of maze-completion time.
Advantages of this experiment?
- The experimental method of this experiment makes it clear to see the cause-effect chain between the neurotransmitter acetylcholine and memory formation.
- Conclusions drawn from this experiment are therefore accurate.
- Multiple trials could have been easily performed
- Easily replicable
- Possiblity that humans can be treated with acetylcholine or physostigmine for memory-loss
- No differences in the role of acetylcholine between cultures (as rats were used, not people); results may be relevant for every human
- No people were harmed in this experiment
- No deception was used in this experiment
Disadvantages of this experiment?
- Rats were harmed
- Ethical concerns to the extent that the rats suffered
- The results cannot be completely applied to humans
Friday, June 21, 2013
Internal Assessment: Montemayor and Eissen (1977)
Hereafter, you will find my original work that I had created in preparation for my internal assessment. Please understand that copying material without giving credit to the source is known as plagiarism and a form of theft. In addition, I recommend you not use this post as the basis for your internal assessment as I am only a student myself, and calling me a reliable source may be debatable in the eyes of teachers and IBO. I am merely posting this as a guideline and example for internal assessments for HL Psychology, so please only use it as one. Thank you and I hope this helps you! - R. B. (Admin)
Topic: Developmental Psychology
Link of original document by Montemayor and Eissen here.
Hypothesis presented in the study: "it is hypothesized that young children primarily conceive of and describe themselves in terms of such concrete characteristics as their physical appearance and possessions, while adolescents conceive of themselves more abstractly and describe themselves in more psychological and interpersonal terms."
What design did Montemayor and Eissen use, and why: Montemayor and Eissen used a controlled laboratory experiment-method because it was the most appropriate design to use for the particular experiment. The nature of a laboratory experiment allows the researchers to control the environment as well as the subjects.
How was the sample selected and how might this influence the study: 136 males and 126 females were selected from four different grade-level schools from suburban, midwestern and university communities. The subjects were either in grades 4, 6, 8, 10 or 12. The subjects were all exclusively white and had average or above average intelligence levels. Almost all of the subject's parents were in classes I and II (Hoolingshead's two factor index of social positions). The focus group may influence the study as the results will not be relevant to the self-perceptions of people of other ethnicities and cultures.
What controls were established? There were no controls other than the students being divided according to their age groups. They were all administered the same test, first created by Burgental & Zelen in 1950, called the Twenty Statements Test. There were 20 spaces were they were directed to defined themselves.
What is the independent and dependent variable? The independent variable is the age group of the subject, and the dependent variable is their quality of self-perception.
Describe the procedures employed by the researcher: Montemayor and Eissen instructed their subjects to complete the Twenty Questions test (question: "Who Am I?") and then had two trained undergraduates to score the answers provided by the subjects according to Gordon's (1968) 30-category scoring system. The 30 categories were those that aimed to classify each and any answer that was written down by the subjects. (E.g: sex, age, name, racial or national heritage, religion, kinship role, occupational role, student role, political affiliation, social status, territoriality or citizenship, membership in actual interacting group, existential or individuating, etc...)
What type of data was gathered? How was it or how could have it been analyzed? Data was gathered within aforementioned 30 categories. The data was processed by the researchers in a way that it was laid out in a table as the percentage of subjects at each age using the category at least once (i.e. quantitative data). Chi-squared tests were also performed due to the large data sets. The researchers explained their data in the form of linear and curvilinear lines.
What are the research findings? Conclusions were made that support the GENERAL hypothesis. The researchers were able to conclude that:
a) The concrete-to-abstract change is not a simple linear one. However, this is most likely because some of the categories can be considered to be either concrete or abstract. The changes between concrete-to-abstract self-perceptions from childhood to adolescence primarily involve the use of concrete description by adolescents rather than the use of abstract self-perceptions by the children.
b) Children in the study primarily described themselves in terms of concrete, objective categories such as their address and physical appearance, while adolescents used more abstract and subjective descriptions such as personal beliefs and interpersonal characteristics.
What types of problems could there have been with the research? Because it was not required that each subject write down all 20 answers, where could have been an uneven amount of data distributed among the age-groups.
What changes could be suggested for future research? Make it compulsory for them to fill out all 20 answers as long as the subjects are willing to participate in the experiment.
Topic: Developmental Psychology
Link of original document by Montemayor and Eissen here.
Hypothesis presented in the study: "it is hypothesized that young children primarily conceive of and describe themselves in terms of such concrete characteristics as their physical appearance and possessions, while adolescents conceive of themselves more abstractly and describe themselves in more psychological and interpersonal terms."
What design did Montemayor and Eissen use, and why: Montemayor and Eissen used a controlled laboratory experiment-method because it was the most appropriate design to use for the particular experiment. The nature of a laboratory experiment allows the researchers to control the environment as well as the subjects.
How was the sample selected and how might this influence the study: 136 males and 126 females were selected from four different grade-level schools from suburban, midwestern and university communities. The subjects were either in grades 4, 6, 8, 10 or 12. The subjects were all exclusively white and had average or above average intelligence levels. Almost all of the subject's parents were in classes I and II (Hoolingshead's two factor index of social positions). The focus group may influence the study as the results will not be relevant to the self-perceptions of people of other ethnicities and cultures.
What controls were established? There were no controls other than the students being divided according to their age groups. They were all administered the same test, first created by Burgental & Zelen in 1950, called the Twenty Statements Test. There were 20 spaces were they were directed to defined themselves.
What is the independent and dependent variable? The independent variable is the age group of the subject, and the dependent variable is their quality of self-perception.
Describe the procedures employed by the researcher: Montemayor and Eissen instructed their subjects to complete the Twenty Questions test (question: "Who Am I?") and then had two trained undergraduates to score the answers provided by the subjects according to Gordon's (1968) 30-category scoring system. The 30 categories were those that aimed to classify each and any answer that was written down by the subjects. (E.g: sex, age, name, racial or national heritage, religion, kinship role, occupational role, student role, political affiliation, social status, territoriality or citizenship, membership in actual interacting group, existential or individuating, etc...)
What type of data was gathered? How was it or how could have it been analyzed? Data was gathered within aforementioned 30 categories. The data was processed by the researchers in a way that it was laid out in a table as the percentage of subjects at each age using the category at least once (i.e. quantitative data). Chi-squared tests were also performed due to the large data sets. The researchers explained their data in the form of linear and curvilinear lines.
What are the research findings? Conclusions were made that support the GENERAL hypothesis. The researchers were able to conclude that:
a) The concrete-to-abstract change is not a simple linear one. However, this is most likely because some of the categories can be considered to be either concrete or abstract. The changes between concrete-to-abstract self-perceptions from childhood to adolescence primarily involve the use of concrete description by adolescents rather than the use of abstract self-perceptions by the children.
b) Children in the study primarily described themselves in terms of concrete, objective categories such as their address and physical appearance, while adolescents used more abstract and subjective descriptions such as personal beliefs and interpersonal characteristics.
What types of problems could there have been with the research? Because it was not required that each subject write down all 20 answers, where could have been an uneven amount of data distributed among the age-groups.
What changes could be suggested for future research? Make it compulsory for them to fill out all 20 answers as long as the subjects are willing to participate in the experiment.
Sunday, May 26, 2013
SLA: All About Bobo Dolls (Albert Bandura 1961)
Social Learning Theory:
Albert Bandura of Stanford University first suggested the Social Learning Theory as a reaction against the passive conception of humans in behaviorism. (He believed that reducing behavior as "stimulus-response" was much too simplistic... he refers to himself as an adherent of social cognitivism.)
- The model can intentionally try to teach an agent how to behave. Examples: teachers, parents, priests
- The model might not try to directly affect the agent. Examples: actors, media, television, passersby
The Social Learning Theory involves the following factors for an agent to be successful in imitating a model:
- Attention: the model performing the act must catch the attention of the agent
- Retention: the agent must be able to remember how the model was acting
- Motor reproduction: the agent must be able to emulate what he observed from the model
- Motivation: the agent must will to perform the observed act
There are also factors that influence the agent's motivation to emulate the observed model:
- Likeness: agents will feel more motivation to emulate a model if they feel alike it it
- Consistency: agents are more likely to copy consistent behavior
- Rewards / punishments: these will act as incentives / deterrents to copy a model (respectively)
- Liking the model: the more an agent likes the model, the higher the chances are that the agent will emulate the model
- E X A M P L E -
Albert Bandura et al. 1961 - Bobo Doll Experiment
- Aim: To see whether children would imitate aggression that they observed modelled by at adult (Social Learning theory). Also, to see whether the gender-likeness of the model would influence the aggression in the children.
- Procedure: Children from the ages of 3-6 years old were used for this study. They were divided into groups depending on their level of aggression, classified by their teachers and their parents. One group of children observed a video of an adult repeatedly beating a Bobo doll.
A second group of children simply saw a video of an adult assembling toys in a room.
A third group saw no video (control group)
*In groups 1 and 2, some children saw same-sex models while others saw different gendered models.
After watching the video, the children were placed in a room with toys and told the toys were for different children. They were then taken to another room with a Bobo doll. - Results: Group 1 (that observed the aggressive model) was the most aggressive group. They expressed physical and verbal aggression. Female subjects were more prone to exercise verbal aggression while male subjects exercised physical aggression. They displayed signs of observational learning.
When the boys saw the female models in the video hitting the Bobo doll, they exclaimed: "Hey! Girls shouldn't act like that!"... thus the agents / subjects were more prone to emulate same-sex models. - Evaluation:
CLA: Further Evaluation of Principles
- Principles in the cognitive level of analysis:
- Human beings are information processors -- mental processes guide behavior:
- The mind can be viewed as a complex machine, like an intelligent, information processing computer. The brain is the hardware, while the mental processing that takes place in the brain is the software. Mental processing is performed in order to make sense of the world. There are ways in which people can make mistakes when they process information, such as by the influence of schemata. (Schemata are mental frameworks developed by previous experiences that influence the way future events and situations are perceived.) In addition, the mind is able to fabricate completely false memories, which can often make our mental processes fallible.
According to the cognitive level of analysis, information input to the mind occurs via bottom-up processing -- from the sensory systems of the organism to the mind. - The mind can be studied scientifically, with the use of developing theories and scientific technology / scientific research methods: New theories that are often developed in the cognitive level of analysis can serve as an amendment for old theories, or can disprove old theories as false. This principle of the cognitive level of analysis is debatable because the research of scientific research methods in studying human behavior means that the studies often lack ecological validity. Cognition should be studied both in the laboratory environment as well as in a daily context.
- Cognitive processes are influenced by both social and cultural factors: Frederic Bartlett (the cognitive psychologist known for coining the term "schema" with his 1932 experiment, War of the Ghosts) was the first to suggest this principle. He observed the effect of cultural cognitive frameworks on memory (aka cultural schemata on memory) and found that the memories were greatly influenced by the subjects' already-possessed frameworks of thinking. He found that people had problems remembering details from stories that are from different cultures. Bartlett demonstrated in his research that memory is not like a tape-recorder, simply recording what is"there", but is a reconstructive process. The reconstructing of memory for recall is why memory has the tendency to be distorted.
BLA: All About Neurotransmitters
Neurotrasmitters
- The Biological Level of Analysis in IB psychology suggests that there are physiological origins of many behaviors
- The Biological Level of Analysis suggests that human beings should be studied as biological organisms
- This view is controversial, so IB psychology attempts to approach human behavior with a holistic view -- considering the cognitive, biological and socio-cultural factors that a person experiences daily -- to determine origins for human behavior
- The relationship between cognition and biology are bidirectional -- cognition can affect biology, while biology can affect cognition
- Many physiological factors play a role in human behavior, such as:
- Brain processes
- Neurotransmitters
- Hormones
- Genes
1. Behavior can be innate
2. Studying animal behaviors can help us understand human behavior
3. There are biological components to behavior -- such as a neurotransmitter for a certain trait
The BLA is often criticized for trying to break down complex and complicated human behavior down into its smallest component parts -- such as into a specific molecule, hormone, neurotransmitter. This is too simplistic an approach to take when we are trying to analyze complex organisms. "There are no easy answers to complex questions"
-N E U R O T R A N S M I T T E R S-
A. Neurons (nerve cells) are one of the building blocks of behavior. Neurons can make up to 13 trillion connections with each other.
B. Neurons relay electrochemical messages to the brain, so the organism can respond to internal and external stimuli
i) When electrochemical messages are sent to the brain, this is called neurotransmission
ii) When an electrochemical impulse travels down the body of the neuron, neurotransmitters are released and cross the synapses (gaps) between the neurons.
iii) Neurotrasmitters can be considered as the body's natural chemical messengers which transmits information transmits information from one neuron to another neuronC. Neurotransmitters have a range of different effects on human behavior, such as:
1) Mood
2) Memory
3) Sexual arousal
4) Mental illness
- E X A M P L E -
Martinez and Kesner 1991 - The Role of the Neurotrasmitter Acetylcholine on Memory Formation -- Aim: To see the role that acetylcholine (a neurotransmitter) has in memory formation
- Acetylcholine: believed to play a role in memory formation, thus the experiment was testing this assumption / hypothesis
- Procedure: The rats learned how to complete a maze that had food at the destination. The rats were then separated into three different groups and:
- Group 1: A group of rats injected with scopolamine, which blocks acetylcholine receptors on the neurons, thus decreasing the available acetylcholine.
- Group 2: A group of rats injected with physostigmine, which blocks the clean up process of cholinesterase, which is responsible for the clean up of acetylcholine from the receptors.
- Group 3: A group of control rats, not treated with anything
- Results: The rats in Group 2 were able to complete the maze quicker than any other rats of the other groups. Group 1 was slowest at completing the race. The control group (Group 3) was able to complete the race at an average pace.
- Interpretation: Acetylcholine is responsible for the formation of memory, as the rats that had blocked acetylcholine receptors were unable to complete the race as efficiently as the other rats. On the other hand, we can also confirm that acetylcholine is responsible for the formation of memory because Group 2 (that had been injected with physostigmine, a compound that prevents cholinesterase from cleaning up the receptor sites and ridding the sites of acetylcholine) was quickest at finding its way through the mazes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



