Showing posts with label Emotions and cognition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Emotions and cognition. Show all posts

Sunday, May 26, 2013

BLA: All About Neurotransmitters

Neurotrasmitters

  • The Biological Level of Analysis in IB psychology suggests that there are physiological origins of many behaviors
  • The Biological Level of Analysis suggests that human beings should be studied as biological organisms
        • This view is controversial, so IB psychology attempts to approach human behavior with a holistic view -- considering the cognitive, biological and socio-cultural factors that a person experiences daily -- to determine origins for human behavior
  • The relationship between cognition and biology are bidirectional -- cognition can affect biology, while biology can affect cognition
  • Many physiological factors play a role in human behavior, such as:
    • Brain processes
    • Neurotransmitters
    • Hormones
    • Genes
Let us first review the three principles of the BLA before proceeding...
1. Behavior can be innate
2. Studying animal behaviors can help us understand human behavior
3. There are biological components to behavior -- such as a neurotransmitter for a certain trait

The BLA is often criticized for trying to break down complex and complicated human behavior down into its smallest component parts -- such as into a specific molecule, hormone, neurotransmitter. This is too simplistic an approach to take when we are trying to analyze complex organisms. "There are no easy answers to complex questions"

-N E U R O T R A N S M I T T E R S-


A. Neurons (nerve cells) are one of the building blocks of behavior. Neurons can make up to 13 trillion connections with each other.
B. Neurons relay electrochemical messages to the brain, so the organism can respond to internal and external stimuli
i) When electrochemical messages are sent to the brain, this is called neurotransmission
ii) When an electrochemical impulse travels down the body of the neuron, neurotransmitters are released and cross the synapses (gaps) between the neurons. 
iii) Neurotrasmitters can be considered as the body's natural chemical messengers which transmits information transmits information from one neuron to another neuron
C. Neurotransmitters have a range of different effects on human behavior, such as:
1) Mood 
2) Memory
3) Sexual arousal
4) Mental illness

- E X A M P L E -

Martinez and Kesner 1991 - The Role of the Neurotrasmitter Acetylcholine on Memory Formation -

  •  Aim: To see the role that acetylcholine (a neurotransmitter) has in memory formation 
    • Acetylcholine: believed to play a role in memory formation, thus the experiment was testing this assumption / hypothesis
  • Procedure: The rats learned how to complete a maze that had food at the destination. The rats were then separated into three different groups and:
    • Group 1: A group of rats injected with scopolamine, which blocks acetylcholine receptors on the neurons, thus decreasing the available acetylcholine.
    • Group 2: A group of rats injected with physostigmine, which blocks the clean up process of cholinesterase, which is responsible for the clean up of acetylcholine from the receptors.
    • Group 3: A group of control rats, not treated with anything
  • Results: The rats in Group 2 were able to complete the maze quicker than any other rats of the other groups. Group 1 was slowest at completing the race. The control group (Group 3) was able to complete the race at an average pace.
  • Interpretation: Acetylcholine is responsible for the formation of memory, as the rats that had blocked acetylcholine receptors were unable to complete the race as efficiently as the other rats. On the other hand, we can also confirm that acetylcholine is responsible for the formation of memory because Group 2 (that had been injected with physostigmine, a compound that prevents cholinesterase from cleaning up the receptor sites and ridding the sites of acetylcholine) was quickest at finding its way through the mazes.
Evaluation of this experiment:






Saturday, April 13, 2013

3.3 CLA Outcomes

Summary of 3.3
Cognitive level of analysis: An integrative look at happiness

Are rich people happier? ... This is not always the case.
According to the psychologist Lyubomirsky (2001), our inborn genetic set-point for happiness can account for up to 50 percent of our own happiness, where as 10 percent is due to circumstances and 40 percent is something that can be influenced by each individual. Happiness is not a concretely constructed concept... it may just be a cultural construction. 

Cognitive factors in happiness: beliefs about happiness:
Although people in the Western world are richer, they are not necessarily happier. This could be because people tend to compare themselves to others. Leon Festinger came up with a cognitive theory called the social comparison theory, where people learn about and assess themselves by comparison with others. According to the social comparison theory, people are happy if they have more than those they normally compare themselves to. Another explanation is that people link happiness to reaching certain goals, but they tend to set higher goals once they have achieved the first ones, therefore they end up never really feeling happy. Julian Rotter proposed the level of aspiration theory. This theory suggests that people examine what they can gain and how likely it is that they will achieve it before they make decisions about what to do. Expectations are influenced by previous experience as well as a desire to reach their goals. People begin to calculate and formulate their general expectancies -  general ideas about what to expect in different situations. People are more motivated to achieve the goals that they set. However, the amount of happiness that is attained as a result of the goals are often too short-lived and minimal.

Myers and Dieners (1995) have shown that there is a contradiction between wealth and happiness. They found that although the proportion of Americans who said that they were very happy remained stable at around 1/3 while the incomes of Americans as a whole increased in the last fifty years. This suggests that there is no direct link between an increase in wealth and happiness. 

Hagerty (2003) studied the relationship between happiness and distributions of wealth. He found that happiness was positively correlated with equality of distribution of wealth in the country. The average level of life satisfaction was high as the inequality of income decreased. This can be explained via Festinger's social comparison theory. People tend to compare themselves to others, and comparing yourself to those who are more fortunate (aka upward comparison) leads to dissatisfaction.

Johnson and Kruger (2006) found that although many people believe there is a relationship between happiness and wealth, it is more "satisfaction with one's own salary that brings happiness." The size of the salary does not matter- the satisfaction of the individual with his/her own salary does. Therefore, if an individual thinks they are not getting paid enough, they are likely to be more dissatisfied. By comparing themselves to those who have higher salaries, they are dissatisfied as well.

Conway, di Fazio and Mayman (1999) from Canada investigated the illusion that "money brings happiness" in a group young males and females. Researchers found that there is a widespread belief that a high-status person was generally happier, less angry, less depressed and experienced less fear in their daily lives than low-status people.
⇒Like these, faulty assumptions and associations with variables are called illusory correlations. ⇒This study demonstrated that there is a positive relationship between wealth and happiness, even though this is not supported by psychological research.

Socio-cultural factors in happiness:

According to the Dalai Lama, the key to happiness is in our own hands. Happiness can be achieved through systematic training of the mind and heart, and through the reshaping of attitudes and outlook. 矢⇒The whole point of life is to be happy.
⇒Happiness is determined by one's state of mind than external conditions, as long as basic survival needs are met.
⇒Compassion for other people is an important part of one's spiritual development. It is also the basis for individual happiness and pleasure.
⇒Dalai Lama: "If people base their happiness on wealth, they will no longer be happy when they lose it. If they base their happiness on connectedness to other people, they will still have something valuable even once they lose all their money. Having empathy and trusting others are important steps toward true happiness."

It is true that average life satisfaction of nations is highly related to income, simply because this is associated with the fulfillment of basic needs and living longer. Experiencing positive emotions is also associated with social variables such as trust, safety and the lack of corruption. (This is positive psychology = psychology with the aim of conducting research that promotes human happiness and well-being)

Biological factors of happiness:
⇒People tend to adapt to their environments.
⇒Humans have inherited the ability to habituate (get used to things) to life's circumstances.
⇒This is why humans seem to get used to pleasant things, and start to take them for granted.
⇒Humans also have inherited the tendency to notice trouble, so we focus on the more troublesome aspects of life.
⇒Humans seem to have an inner voice of dissatisfaction that prompts us to strive for MORE.

Genetics:
David Lykken: "We have an innate base-line or set-point of happiness that depends largely on the individual." The Happiness Twin Study conducted by David Lykken et al in 1996, which compared happiness scores among sets of identical and fraternal twins who grew up together or were reared apart. If the twins have similar happiness levels but are reared apart, then happiness must be genetic. ⇒Researchers found that identical twins had very similar happiness scores, and fraternal twins did not: leading them to conclude that each individual has a genetically influenced set-point for happiness, and that 50 percent of the difficulties in a person's happiness level is genetically determined.
The researchers also suggested that only 10 percent of the variance in happiness levels can be explained by situation factors. This is supported by research where richer and more beautiful people are not happier than the average person. Therefore, 40 percent of happiness remains to be in the control of the individual. 

Typical characteristics of happy people, according to Sonja Lyubomirsky in The How of Happiness
  • They devote time to family and friends
  • They can express gratitude for what they have
  • They are the first to volunteer to help others
  • They are naturally optimistic
  • They enjoy pleasures of live and live in the present
  • They spend time doing physical activities
  • They are committed to lifelong goals 
  • They cope well in calamities

Friday, April 12, 2013

3.2 CLA Outcomes

Learning outcomes for 3.2
Cognitive Level of Analysis: Cognition and Emotion

A little insight into the power of emotions in cognitive processes:

- People remember better the experiences that involve emotions. Emotions are rich and diverse, and they are often what make the experience something special. Antonio Damasio, a brain researcher explains that emotions are simply the physical signs of the body which react to outside/external stimuli.
- The three components of emotion:
Physiological changes; arousal of the autonomic nervous system and the endocrine system that are not conscious
Subjective feelings; a person's own subjective feeling of an emotion (e.g. happiness)
Associated behavior; such as smiling [happy] or running away [frightened]
- A perceived dangerous event or stimulus will result in a physiological response known as fight or flight, which prepares the individual for direct action to confront the danger or to avoid to, and a cognitive appraisal of arousal - a decision about what to do based on previous experience.



- Discuss the extent to which cognitive and biological factors interact in emotion:

① Biological factors in emotion: 

The amygdala is a small structure in the temporal love that is known to be critical in the brain's emotional circuit. The amygdala is thought to have an important role in emotional memories. 
Studies performed on animals and humans indicate that the stress hormones (e.g. adrenaline) are released when strong emotions are evoked.
LeDoux's model of biological pathways of emotion in the brain
In The Emotional Brain (1999), the author LeDoux delineates two biological pathways of emotions in the brain.
  1. Short route: goes from the thalamus to the amygdala for induction of emotional response
  2. Long route: passes via neocortex and hippocampus before reaching an emotional response 
The amygdala receives input from the sensory processing areas in the neocortex and thamalus, and projects / expresses these to areas in the brainstem that control response systems. The connections in between the different brain structures is what allow the amygdala  to transform sensory information into emotional signals and to control our emotional responses.

Most of these processes are non-conscious.

According to LeDoux, the advantages of having direct and indirect pathways to the amygdala is flexibility in responses. When danger is perceived, the fast and direct pathway is useful because it saves time. Long pathways are useful because they allow for a more thorough evaluation of a situation that can help people and animals to avoid inappropriate responses to certain situations.


② Cognitive factors in emotion - appraisal:

Lazarus' definition of appraisal: evaluations related to how the situation will impact one's personal well-being. If the appraisal is positive: positive emotions will emerge. If the appraisal is negative: appraisal that assesses potential harm will result in negative emotions.

Lazarus (1975): "Cognitive appraisal is an important part of people's reaction to emotional stress , and that stress experiences are not only physiological." This statement means that people are psychological beings that are not simply passively responding to the world - they actively interpret and evaluate their situation.

- According to the appraisal theory, cognitive factors can modulate stress responses, such as the psychological and physiological reactions that are involved in the experience.
- Appraisal can be seen as an evaluation of the situation, like how people evaluate psychological and material resources to cope with the stressful event at hand.

⇒Speisman et al. (1964) An Experimental Manipulation of Emotions Through Cognitive Appraisal
Aim: To investigate the extent to which manipulation of cognitive appraisal could influence emotional experience.
Procedure: In this laboratory experiment, the participants saw anxiety-evoking films, such as one with an aboriginal initiation ceremony  where adolescent boys were subjected to unpleasant genital cutting.These films were shown with three different soundtracks that were intended to manipulate emotional reactions. The trauma condition group has a soundtrack with emphasis on the mutilation and pain; the intellectualization condition group has a soundtrack that gave an anthropological interpretation of the initiation ceremony; the denial condition group showed the adolescents as being willing and happy in the ceremony.
During each viewing of the film various objective physiological measures were taken, such as heart rate and galvanic skin response.

Results: The participants in the trauma condition group showed higher physiological measures of stress than the participants in the other two conditions. The results support the appraisal theory in that the manipulation of the participants' cognitive appraisal had significant impacts on the physiological stress reactions. The participants in the trauma condition reacted much more emotionally.
Evaluation: This lab experiment had a lot of controls, so lacks ecological validity. However, research on the role of appraisal in real-life emotional events tend to find the same relationship as the lab results. This study could be a demonstration of how biological and cognitive factors interact in emotion and illustrates LeDoux's theory of the two pathways in emotional processing.

Cognitive and biological factors interact in emotion to a large extent, but in complex ways tat are not well known. Emotions may influence cognitive processes such as memory, and cognitive processes like appraisal can influence emotions, but little is known about the exact workings of the physiological correlates of emotion.
The influence is often bidirectional and this has been explored within health and abnormal psychology. Neuroimaging investigators of emotion have identified areas in the prefrontal loves associated with active reappraisal of the emotional importance of events. This indicates that it is possible to regulate negative emotions via appraisal.
(Ochsner and Gross, 2008).



- Evaluate one theory of how emotions may affect one cognitive process (flashbulb theory)
According to LeDoux, the arousal of emotion can facilitate the memory of events that occur during that aroused state. However, these memories might not always be accurate.
The theory of the flashbulb memory was suggested by Brown and Kulik (1977). Flashbulb memory is a special kind of emotional memory which refers to vivid and detailed memories of very emotional events that appear to be recorded in the brain as though with the help of a camera's flash. 
Brown and Kulik found that people said that they had very clear memories of where they were, what they did and what they felt when they first learned about an important public occurrence, such as assassinations of JFK, and Martin Luther King. The participants of the study recalled the assassination of JFK most vividly. People in the study were also asked if they had flashbulb memories of personal events... out of the 80 participants, 73 participants said that they had flashbulb memories associated with a personal shock such as a sudden death of a close relative.
Brown and Kulik suggested that there might be a special neural mechanism that triggers an emotional arousal because the event is unexpected or very important. This was only a hypothesis, but it is supported by modern neuroscience. (That is, emotional events are better remembered than less emotional events - perhaps because of the critical role of amygdala.)

Criticisms of the flashbulb theory:
Neisser (1982) questioned the idea of the flashbulb theory because people don't always know that an event important, until later. Neisser suggests that the memories are so vivid because the event itself is rehearsed and reconsidered after the event. According to Neisser, what is called a flashbulb memory might just be a narrative convention. These flashbulb memories are governed by a story-telling schema that follows a specific structure, such as place (where we were), activity (doing what?), informant  (who told us?) and affect (how do we feel about it?).

Example: January 28th, 1986:
Seven astronauts on the space shuttle CHALLENGER were killed in an accident. It was a shocking experience for those who saw the shuttle launch, in person or through the TV. Neisser and Harsch (1992) investigated people's memory accuracy of the incident 24 hours after the accident and once again two years later. The participants were confident that their memory was correct, but the researchers found that 40 percent of the memories were distorted in their final reports. Perhaps post-event information had influenced their memories. The researchers concluded that inaccuracy of emotional memories is very common.

It has been stated that current attitudes and emotions also affect the accuracy of memory. Past emotional memories are partly reconstructed based on the individual's current appraisal of events.
Holmberg and Holmes (1994) = found that men who had less happy marriages recalled early interactions in the marriage as being more negative than they really were.
Breckler (1994) = found that people's current attitudes towards blood donation impacted their memories about how they felt when they donated blood in the past.
*These are just theories.